Key highlights
- Neither structure is automatically cheaper for every business
- A loan leads to ownership; a lease often lowers upfront cash
- Tax treatment and how long you keep the asset are decisive
- Compare total cost including residual, not just repayments
Neither an equipment loan nor a lease is automatically cheaper; which costs less depends on whether you want to own the asset, your tax position, how long you will keep it and the total cost including any residual. A loan like a chattel mortgage leads to ownership and can suit depreciating assets you keep long term, while a lease can lower cash outlay and suit assets you upgrade often. Overdrive compares 80+ lenders across both structures on total cost.
How the two differ
With an equipment loan such as a chattel mortgage, the asset is yours from day one and the finance is secured against it; you repay principal and interest and own it outright at the end, subject to any balloon. With a lease, the financier retains ownership and you pay to use the asset over the term, often with a residual or the option to buy at the end. That ownership difference drives most of the cost and tax distinctions, so understanding it is the starting point for deciding which is cheaper for you.
The cost comparison is not straightforward
On repayments alone, a lease can look cheaper because you are financing use rather than the full purchase, and a residual keeps monthly costs down. But a residual is a lump sum owing at the end, and over the full life of ownership a loan can work out less if you keep the asset long term. Conversely, if you upgrade frequently, a lease may cost less overall because you never carry a depreciating, ageing asset. The honest answer is that total cost depends on your specific numbers and timeline, which is why a blanket rule about which is cheaper rarely holds up once you run the figures for your own deal.
Tax treatment can tip the balance
Tax often influences which structure is cheaper after tax. With a chattel mortgage you can generally claim depreciation on the asset and the interest on the loan, and the GST on the purchase price is typically handled upfront. With a lease, the repayments are usually treated as an operating expense and may be deductible, with GST applied to the rentals. Which is more favourable depends on your circumstances, so the tax effect can change the real cost meaningfully. Always check with your accountant before deciding on this basis, as the right answer for your business can differ from a general rule of thumb.
How long you keep the asset
Your holding period is one of the biggest cost drivers. If you plan to own equipment for its full working life, a loan that ends in ownership usually delivers better long-term value, because after the term you have an asset with no more repayments. If you like to upgrade every few years to stay current, a lease can be cheaper and simpler, avoiding the effort of selling an ageing asset and letting you roll into new equipment. Matching the structure to your upgrade cycle is key to minimising cost, so think honestly about how long this particular asset will earn its keep in your business.
Compare total cost, not repayments
The trap is comparing monthly repayments in isolation, since a lease or a loan with a big balloon shows low repayments but leaves a lump sum owing. To know which truly costs less, compare the total amount paid over the term plus any residual or balloon, and factor in the after-tax position and the asset's value to you at the end. Overdrive takes one application and compares 80+ banks and non-bank lenders across both loans and leases, presented on total cost so the real winner is clear. That way you compare the genuine end-to-end cost of each option rather than being misled by a tempting monthly figure.
Deciding between a loan and a lease comes down to your ownership goals, tax position and timeline, and the numbers rarely speak for themselves at a glance. Send Overdrive your asset and business details for an indicative, no-obligation comparison across 80+ lenders and both structures, laid out on total cost. Pair that with a quick word to your accountant on the tax angle, and you will have everything you need to choose the option that genuinely costs your business less.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a lease always cheaper than a loan?
No. A lease can show lower monthly repayments, but a residual leaves a lump sum owing, and over the full life of an asset a loan ending in ownership can cost less. Which is cheaper depends on how long you keep the asset, your tax position and the total cost including any residual, not the monthly figure alone.
Which structure is better for tax?
It depends on your circumstances. A chattel mortgage generally lets you claim depreciation and interest, while lease payments are often treated as a deductible operating expense, with GST handled differently in each. The more favourable option varies by business, so it is general information only and you should check with your accountant before deciding on tax grounds.
Do I own the equipment with a lease?
Not during the term. With a lease the financier owns the asset and you pay to use it, often with a residual or an option to purchase at the end. With a loan such as a chattel mortgage you own the asset from the start. If ownership matters to you, a loan structure is usually the better fit.
Which suits a business that upgrades often?
A lease often suits businesses that refresh equipment frequently, because you finance use rather than ownership and can roll into new assets without holding an ageing, depreciating one. If you keep equipment for its full working life instead, a loan that ends in ownership generally offers better long-term value. Your upgrade cycle is a key factor.
Ready to compare cheap rates?
Free quote in minutes, decisions in 24–48 hours. No credit-score impact to enquire.